Emdashes—Modern Times Between the Lines

The Basics:
About Emdashes | Email us

Before it moved to The New Yorker:
Ask the Librarians

Best of Emdashes: Hit Parade
A Web Comic: The Wavy Rule

 
March272006

Every Other Day of the Week Is Fine

Filed under: Headline Shooter

Monday, Monday links:

As Blog About Town (winner [actually co-winner; thanks for the modest correction!], by the way, of Emily Richards' own recent contest) reports, Carl Gable has conquered caption contest #40 with "Well, that was abominable." Well done! It's a good time to bow to the other contestants, including Boston's Lou Rubino ("I think the Manhattan skyline is getting suspicious"), whom the Globe profiled as he waited for the results. The paper notes that Boston has been a winner's town, and the winners are enjoying their sparkly status:


Now, music librarian Andrew Wilson of Ayer has a standing offer to write for a greeting card company. Fifth-grade teacher Miriam Steinberg of Cambridge gets congratulated by her students' parents. Sarah Bell, a fund-raising assistant, has strangers recognize her name months after it appeared in the magazine.

''My friend's uncle was joking I should just go around captioning things in the house," said Bell, 23, of Cambridge.

''People who are die-hard New Yorker readers thought it was really great," she said. ''It was just fun to see someone they knew win. Like my grandmother. But people didn't look at me like I was any smarter. My friends probably know better."

In The New Republic, Helen Vendler reviews the new Elizabeth Bishop collection, edited by Alice Quinn. Brace yourself.

Inside Higher Education responds to the Kenyon kontroversy about gender-biased admissions, and to Katha Pollitt's retort in her Nation blog (I can't bear to type "The Notion").

Last but certainly not least, Laurie Abraham, writing in Elle, takes a long look at feminish du jour Caitlin Flanagan:

For many women of my acquaintance, reading essayist Caitlin Flanagan is like deciding to take a walk through the woods in the fall during hunting season. The colors are so gorgeous, they call to you. The pungent smell of the literary terrain is reassuringly familiar. Really, what could hurt you in here, in this forest of glittering words? Still, you're alert, watching for strange movements, threatening forms. After writing a series of controversial pieces in The Atlantic Monthly, Flanagan was tapped to cover family life for The New Yorker, and the essay that arrived in a recent issue is about P. L. Travers, the deceased author of Mary Poppins. What could be more delightful? More good fun? It's the kind of tale that Flanagan's father, a highly regarded novelist, professor of Irish literature, and New York Review of Books intellectual, excelled at: “potted biographies,” as one admiring reviewer described the pieces in Thomas Flanagan's posthumous collection There You Are, “rich in detail, telling of Eugene O'Neill's fascination with the sea, F. Scott Fitzgerald's love of Keats....”

Yet each step further into the dimming light is more halting. Irish poet Seamus Heaney said that though his friend Tom wielded a rhetorical sword, “it would be wrong to ascribe murderousness to the blade.” His daughter may be a different story. Mary Poppins was a nanny, after all, and Caitlin Flanagan on nannies—is that the sound of crunching leaves?

“I read the article she wrote in The Atlantic, and I just felt crucified,” says the best-selling novelist Jennifer Weiner, referring to Flanagan's most infamous piece, “How Serfdom Saved the Women's Movement.” In it, she argues that professional women have entered the workforce on the backs of poor immigrant nannies and that the children of these lawyers and doctors and executives love their nannies more than they do their own mothers: “To con oneself into thinking that the person who provides daily physical care to a child is not the one he is going to love in a singular and primal way—a way obviously designed by nature herself to cleave child to mother and vice versa—is to ignore one of the most fundamental truths of childhood.” Weiner had just hired someone to care for her infant daughter 20 hours a week.

Oh, here it comes. Get ready to throw yourself to the ground, girls, press your face into the wetness. Continued.

Comments

Thanks for the nod, Emily! Let’s not forget that I’m actually a co-winner—it’s worth noting that, as Emily Richards herself put it, “the hilarious Walt came up with a succinct and absurd analogy.”

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, it may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Thanks for waiting.)

2008 Webby Awards Official Honoree