Monthly Archives: May 2005

May I tempt you with “A Chip Off the Old Benchley” tonight, sir?

And speaking of the Algonquin!

Take the Apple iPod, add a best-selling novel – Ian McEwen’s “Saturday” will do nicely – and mix in the venerable Algonquin Hotel. The result: a marketing gimmick with high-tech overtones for a low-tech product.

The 174-room Algonquin on West 45th Street, renowned for its fat, gossipy literary history through the decades – a history that features Dorothy Parker, New Yorker editor William Shawn and many others – now offers a battery-operated take on reading, or, rather, listening: Guests will be able to take a loaner iPod to bed, preloaded by staff with the audio book of their choice.

The iPods – there are two on hand to start – will be loaned at no cost on a first-come, first-served basis, and guests can choose from a selection of classics and current bestsellers.

I have, since my last post, scored an interview with Matilda. You’ll read it as soon as I write it, which will happen just after I have it.

Cool 2 Use [Stephen Williams, Newsday]

Hersh harsh; hecklers, hoorahs

Putting the “humane” into doctor of humane letters, Seymour Hersh speaks truth to youth (from a piece in yesterday’s Newsday). I’m curious—how may of the 6,000 people listening were booing, roughly speaking, and how many were cheering? Making actions the subject of a sentence has a way of smoothing over these little distinctions. Hersh’s final remarks remind me of those made by my own college commencement speaker—this was then-president Ellen Futter, who was about to leave Morningside Heights for her fancy new job as president of the Natural History Museum. Anyway, as we shivered in the cold May rain and our grandparents got dripped on, Futter spoke to us of a world full of unfairness and atrocities, a grim economy and an uncertain future, a shredded environment and general bad times all around. I prefer the specificity of Hersh’s comments, which give you something to work with other than a state of mind like the one that promped Woody Allen to say, “I have an intense desire to return to the womb. Anybody’s.”

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. — Journalist Seymour Hersh described U.S. soldiers in Iraq as “victims,” eliciting jeers and cheers from an audience of about 6,000 people at a college commencement on Monday.

Hersh, speaking to graduates of Fairleigh Dickinson University and their families, said American soldiers are “doing an admirable job under terrible conditions” but don’t know much about the war they are fighting.

“They are as much victims as the people they are sometimes forced to kill,” Hersh said.

The comment was greeted by a loud expletive from one member of the audience. Booing and more swearing followed, but other audience members stood and cheered.

Hersh, who was among the first to report on the abuse of Iraqi inmates at Abu Ghraib prison, was awarded an honorary doctor of humane letters degree.

He spoke for about five minutes, introducing himself as “a huge critic of my government,” but praising the United States for allowing dissent.

He concluded his five-minute speech by saying, “And I’m sorry for the disquieting comments, but that’s what it’s all about, folks. Happy graduation.”

A Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, Hersh is a regulator [sic, but what a sic! who’s watching the watchers’ watchers?] contributor to The New Yorker magazine and the author of eight books.

At college commencement, Hersh describes U.S. soldiers as ‘victims’ [AP, via Newsday]
Hersh’s 2003 Columbia J-school commencement address [Columbia]

Categories:

(5.23.05 issue) Caption contest: duh

Once again, an obvious choice: “Would it kill you to use a few of your roaming minutes?” by Jennifer Cain of—hooray!—Brooklyn, N.Y. And again, I’m a little shocked at the choices here. #1 is a poor efffort, and not realistically worded either. #3 is good in that (as Bob Mankoff has emphasized) one of the best things you can do with a caption is turn the obvious assumption about the drawing’s players on its head. So, here, yes, maybe the emergency-hotline woman yelling down to the bedraggled guy actually knows him. But is this the funniest thing one can think of for her to say? It’s almost funny if you stretch it in your head—Doug the wretch always looks like this and this is their weird erotic ritual, perhaps—but if that’s the case I’m still not amused, just sort of vaguely interested. That’s not enough to win a contest. Jennifer, as far as I’m concerned, you’ve got it. If you win, I’ll buy you a cup of coffee at the Brooklyn diner of your choice.

Categories: , ,

I believe in yesterday

Because yesterday, I went on the Algonquin Round Table Walking Tour with the Dorothy Parker Society‘s tireless and terrifically well-informed Kevin Fitzpatrick (and a dozen or so extremely pleasant walking companions). We walked, we barely escaped an especially greasy-smoky street fair; we saw the places where magazines were made, follies were performed, and livers were shot. We talked, we didn’t get rained on, and, thoroughly ravenous, we went back to the hotel for a late lunch at the round table, yes, the round table, and most of us had very small hamburgers (three), named after Dorothy Parker and served with very small bottles of ketchup. I reprised my coconut martini from the night I haven’t written about yet, in which I dined alone and met a French movie star who was not doing a very good job remaining incognito. I petted Matilda, the hotel cat, who has an entitled yet gracious air. It was a good day. I’ll write about it in more detail in the next few days. I might as well throw in that other Algonquin post too, since it features a review of their steak sandwich (preview: yum). Did I mention I hobnobbed with un homme francais fameuse? I mean fameus? Oui, I did. The coconut martinis were helpful in that enterprise. They have a pineapple wedge.

Caption contest: Squid ink

Some pretty funny entries by this guy from the first (Squiddy the Chef) cartoon caption contest:

Here’s my entry: “I can’t in good conscience recommend the hand rolls tonight.”

My runners-up:

“Well, the tuna never takes it personally. Try that.”

“Yes, ever since we were kids. Honestly, he hasn’t given it much thought.”

“Work release program. It was either this, or menace the shipping lanes.”

“Extra wasabi? Won’t make much difference either way.”

“The special requires real teamwork to bring to the table.”

As he says, “I’m planning to submit an entry each week until I’m asked to ‘please stop doing that.’ ” Now, that’s the kind of attitude I like. I’m officially supporting Matt Shobe to win the next contest. If a bribery opportunity becomes available, I’ll take it. And for the love of Pete (or in this case, Leo—no, not the NYer‘s fair Leo Carey; sorry girls, he’s taken), don’t forget to vote today in the current contest! In case you’ve forgotten already, here’s my endorsement.

And if you want to be more like Matt here, put your thinking cap on and enter the current contest. I can hear you right now; you’re whining, But I just like making sour little quips with my friends all day long on the internet—I don’t like exposing myself like that! That is lame. (Here’s an upsetting account of cartoon caption contest writers’ block.) Both contests expire at the stroke of midnight tonight, so go. If you need more inspiration, here’s an interview with Dan Heath, the winner of the squid contest: “The mystery of the cartoon is: doesn’t he see how wrong it is? He’s selling out his own kind! I got really worked up about it. It’s like a little morality play with tentacles.” See, he’s a famous man now! This could be you!

The Squid Stays in the Picture [Q. & A. with cartoonist Alex Gregory, New Yorker]
Cartoon Charisma: Capturing the Moment [Boston Phoenix]
New Yorker State of Mind [Eye’s Guy Leshinski, on the contest]

Categories: , ,

The less mysterious Ms. Quinn

In this archived interview with Alice Quinn from the Christian Science Monitor‘s good series, Quinn tackles these questions, among others:

How did you get started at The New Yorker?

What is the mission of The New Yorker, and how does poetry contribute to that mission?

How do you know when you are on track with readers? And when you are trying to reach a range of readers, how do you also set a standard in poetry?

What’s the selection process like for poetry at the magazine?

Poetry used to have a much larger audience (for example, the military sent thousands of copies of a Robert Frost book to soldiers). Can you shed some light on this?

What are some of the most significant trends in poetry that you’ve seen during your time at The New Yorker?

Have poets accepted the mistaken notion that poetry is a dying art form?

Should a poet have a public role other than teacher or ambassador?

A lot of people like old poetry more than contemporary work, which they feel is self-absorbed and has no universality. How would you respond to that?

What is the one issue that people need to be discussing but aren’t?

For a more skeptical perspective on the magazine’s poetic tone, here’s an interview with the editor of Light: A Quarterly of Light Verse. I see it all around me, this need to put “serious” and “funny” poetry at odds. I don’t see the conflict. Poets who never write anything silly might want to try it—I find it cheers me up; schticky “funny” poets (let’s say Billy Collins as a popular example) are usually writing about serious things (comedy and mortality—hasn’t this connection been proved to…death?). So poets divide and conquer themselves for fear of crossing genre lines. If we’re going to take back the world, people, we’d better start by agreeing that what we’re doing isn’t all that different.

Great Scotts

The staggeringly well-read Scott McLemee has reminded me (on his blog) to revisit The Dullest Blog in the World. The satire’s good, as always (“I was in a room carrying out some routine activities. I began to consider playing some music on the stereo system. I looked at some compact discs for a while, but didn’t put one on”), but it’s the exact same joke that Onion founder Scott Dikkers used about five hundred times—to great effect—for his small but immensely negative (in many senses) comic strip, Jim’s Journal. If you like anti-jokes and existential themes explored in insultingly simple line drawings, as I do, the anthology is definitely for you.

Also from Scott: a blog called Minor Tweaks, which is a perfect name and I crave it. Here’s MT (a.k.a. Tom Bartlett) on how he’s cheaper than Paris Hilton and some Dead Celebrity iTunes Playlists. (Speaking of Paris and her as yet unconceived children Paris and London, don’t skip this totally ridiculous AP interview, which contains the now infamous exchange “What did you want to be when you were a little girl?” “A veterinarian, but then I realized I could just buy a bunch of animals.” Thanks to DP for the tip!)

And I wouldn’t feel right if I didn’t mention this brief guide for journalists writing about the recently announced Rolling Stones world tour:

Make use of the band’s song titles to spice up that bland lead. Example: “It seems the Rolling Stones still can’t get no satisfaction.” Or “Start them up! Mick and Keith are preparing to embark …” Stay away from more obscure Stones songs. If you write “They may not be taking a silver train, but the Rolling Stones are hitting the road” most people won’t know what you’re talking about.

The members of the Rolling Stones are old. This should be mentioned often and high in the story. Consider playing with the name of the band a bit. Example: “The Rolling Stones are determined not to gather moss.” Or turn it around and say: “The Rolling Stones may be gathering moss but that doesn’t mean they can’t rock.”

When mentioning when the band will be in your area, don’t say “The Rolling Stones will arrive in TKTK on TKTK.” Instead say “The Stones will roll into town … ” See the difference?

Follow these simple rules and you will be on your way to writing a first-rate Rolling Stones article. And remember: Sometimes you can get what you want!

At the end of the day, real jokes still beat anti-jokes. Acknowledging the basic fruitlessness of human existence is important, but so is grinning.

My necktie rich and modest

Truly the story of the image of poets in our age: “Acclaimed poet keeps his day job selling suits at The Gardens mall,” from the South Florida Sun-Sentinel. The reporter-game-for-an-arts-assignment piece is worth quoting in its entirety (with boldface emphasis by me):

Acclaimed poet keeps his day job selling suits at The Gardens mall

By Mike Clary
Staff Writer
Posted May 2 2005

Amid the shelves of precisely folded dress shirts, in the routine and punctuality required of a Brooks Brothers clerk, Spencer Reece found the perfect antidote to a life of emotional turmoil.

Grounded by his daily toil in retail, he started a savings account, took a lover and finished a collection of poems 15 years in the making.

But don’t suppose, just because the gangly Juno Beach resident has been hailed by The New Yorker, won a prestigious poetry prize and published a first book greeted with acclaim, that he will quit his day job at The Gardens mall in Palm Beach Gardens.

“I need my job,” said Reece, 41. “It taught me about life, to be a team player, to work with others. I know it seems pedestrian. But it suits me.”

Published last year by Houghton Mifflin Co., “The Clerk’s Tale” is as thin and spare as its author, yet eloquent in its spot-on depiction of life shot through with longing and loss.

“I do not know a contemporary book in which poems so dazzlingly entertaining contain, tacitly, so much sorrow,” wrote former U.S. poet laureate Louise Glück in the book’s introduction.

Glück recommended Reece’s work to New Yorker poetry editor Alice Quinn, who in June 2003 devoted the entire back page of the magazine’s fiction issue to the title poem of the collection. She said his collection is “one of the most moving and unified first books I’ve read.”

In the past few months, Reece has done readings at the Library of Congress and at book fairs in Los Angeles and Texas, and won grants from the Guggenheim Memorial Foundation and the National Endowment for the Arts. And he has begun several new poems.

Still, Reece is a poet and a clerk, as much at home now with pinpoint and broadcloth as with the meter and rhyme.

“Poetry is meditative, and requires an amount of silence,” Reece said, “and the store is all noise, movement and fractured interchanges.”

In a world where too few read, and fewer still read verse, poetry does not pay. But Brooks Brothers does – about $30,000 a year for an assistant manager.

The life of a poet has never been easy. As a youth, Lord Alfred Tennyson was dogged by poverty. W.B. Yeats suffered from unrequited love. Ezra Pound and Robert Lowell were haunted by madness.

From a privileged beginning, as the son of a well-to-do Minnesota physician, Reece, too, found anguish. After studying at Bowdoin College and Wesleyan University, he earned a master’s degree in English Renaissance poetry in York, England, and then entered Harvard Divinity School. Headed toward a career in the ministry, he was awarded a master’s degree in theology in 1990.

After returning to Minnesota to live on the family farm, Reece’s world crumbled. His parents went bankrupt and could not accept their son’s homosexuality. He became estranged from his younger brother.

Nearing a breakdown, Reece said he committed himself to a mental hospital in 1994. “When I speak of the weather, is it because I cannot speak of my days spent in the nuthouse?” he writes in his poem Florida Ghazals.

After his hospital stay, Reece needed a job, and found it at Brooks Brothers in the Mall of America outside Minneapolis. “At first I thought it wouldn’t suit me,” he said. “But the job became a good fit.”

Reece transferred to the Palm Beach store in 1998, and four years ago moved to The Gardens, store No. 52, where he rose to assistant manager.

His boss, store manager Ellen Morris, said Reece’s success as a poet has not infringed on his role as a valued employee. “I think he is humbled by what’s happened to him after all these years of trying to get published,” she said. “It has not changed him. He’s a good person.”

Reece’s partner, Paul McNamara, 52, who has a business repairing car interiors, admits, “I’m not a literary guy.”

Yet, said McNamara, Reece “has an open heart. He can really engage the audience. I like watching him perform.”

Out of his formal Brooks Brothers attire on a recent day off, Reece wears Madras shorts, a white shirt, Ray-Ban shades and, from his most recent out-of-town reading, a ball cap stitched with the slogan “Keep Austin Weird.”

During a meandering trek from the beach in Lantana, Fla., to a nearby apartment house, where he lived until moving in with McNamara, Reece is asked to take the measure of his life at midpoint.

Like Prufrock in the T.S. Eliot poem, which has served as one of his touchstones, Reece worries aloud about growing old, about estrangements and opportunities lost.

Yet he is happy where he is, being of service and working with others. Pausing near a dock on the Intracoastal Waterway, Reece recalled a store party the staff threw for him when his book was published.

“They are not readers,” he said. “But they had a party and I cried. I didn’t think they cared that much. But they do.”

Also like J. Alfred Prufrock, I experienced many emotions while reading this piece. One was gratitude that a regular newspaper bothered to interview a mid-career, first-book poet about his life and work. That’s so nice. I was touched by Reece’s difficult journey (the boyfriend sounds like a sweetie) and pleased for him about his success (even despite my bitterness at Louise Gluck’s somehow having passed me over for Yale Younger Poets). And yet I find it all so incredible—the idea that any poet could quit his day job after the a single book’s publication. $30,000 a year? Hang onto your silk socks, friend! It’s not going to get much better than that, especially if you’re an adjunct.

Blogger ate the rest of this post after it went up, but I think the gist was that poets don’t make a nickel, even in academia (supposedly the gold at the end of the sellout rainbow, but I haven’t seen it work that way till people are on their maybe fourth book, and well into their fifties). Forget about Tennyson (I love that aside about Yeats suffering from unrequited love, by the way!)—Spencer Reece needs his job, Louise Gluck needs her job, and so does every other poet you’ve ever heard of or not heard of. Oh, I know; I also said Brooks Bros. should start hiring poets in all their stores—to provide excellent outfit descriptions on the sales floor (we’re good with colors), exude sensitivity and taste, and celebrate with the staff at each publication. I think it would benefit everyone.