Author Archives: Emdashes

Brody and Scott on Realism, and Raban on Northwestern Reality

Jonathan Taylor writes:

A.O. Scott has posted a reply to Richard Brody’s Front Row critique of his Times magazine article on “neo-neorealism.”
I’ll note in passing “Metronatural America,” an article by Jonathan Raban from a recent New York Review of Books about the films of Kelly Reichardt, particularly “Wendy and Lucy.” I think Raban captures the “complexity and ambiguity” in these films that Brody suggests is lacking. At the same time, the contrast Raban notes between these films and the stories of Jon Raymond in Livability (from which both “Old Joy” and “Wendy and Lucy” were adapted) perhaps jibes superficially with Brody’s claim that the movies put “emphasis on outer life at the expense of inner life”:

Where Kelly Reichardt practises a strict, Carveresque minimalism, leaving out far more than she puts in, Raymond is a prose maximalist. Although his characters have difficulty relating to each other, they relate to the reader with unbuttoned, occasionally garrulous, intimacy. To the reader alone, they entrust their memories, thoughts, feelings, landscape descriptions, even as they explain to the reader why these private riches can’t be shared with the person closest to them in the story.

Still, I think that what Reichardt does with “the outer life” and the constraints it puts on the conduct of “the inner life,” is as profound a portrait of the latter as anything.
I was recently talking to a friend about “Old Joy,” and the question of whether it was “depressing” came up; to which I responded that I did find it a bit depressing, but was thrilled, in a way, that it had left me precisely as mildly depressed as might be described as my resting state. For me solipsistically, at least, an indicator of the film’s unusual “realism.”

Sempé Fi (On Covers): Elle

Floc'h_MichelleO_3-16-09.jpg
_Pollux writes_:
The _Chicago Tribune_ “once asked”:http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/politics/obama/chi-michelle-obama-dress-story,0,1949360.story, “With her gumball pearls, flip hairstyle and chic dresses, could Michelle Obama be the next Jacqueline Kennedy for stylephiles?” The March 16, 2009 issue of _The New Yorker_ is “The Style Issue” and who better to grace its cover than Mrs. Obama, who has quickly become a new fashion icon and a new source of fashion excitement? Michelle Obama is, “as one French blog described her”:http://lhommedanslafoule.blogspot.com/2009/03/new-yorker-couverture-16-mars-2009.html, _la nouvelle first lady des Etats Unis d’Amérique pour un numéro “The Style Issue.”_
That Michelle Obama has chosen to wear the most exciting names in American fashion is an indication of the qualities that also characterize her husband: confidence, self-assurance, elegance, and optimism. Having assumed the mantle of fashion icon, the First Lady has taken advantage of this new role to wear clothes designed not by established, big-name designers, but by rising stars in the world of fashion (Jason Wu, Isabel Toledo, Jimmy Choo), and she has mixed designer clothes with brands like J. Crew.
The choice of “Floc’h”:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Floc%27h as cover artist is significant: a practitioner of the precise drawing style known as _ligne claire_, Floc’h has contributed illustrations to _Elle_ and _GQ_. The French cartoonist has also created drawings for the Parisian men’s wear shop known as Albert’s on the Rue de Courcelles, and contributed “fashion sketches”:http://www.breuer.fr/site.html for the Spring-Summer 2009 catalogue for the Breuer house of fashion.
His enormous output (Floc’h has been an illustrator since the late ’70s) includes “book cover designs”:http://bookdesign.wordpress.com/2008/12/22/floch-illustrateur-de-livres/, movie posters, and collections of comics often issued as handsome limited editions bound like portfolios and replete with lavish lithographs. Floc’h’s collaboration with the writer François Rivière, _Une trilogie anglaise_, which features the adventures of Olivia Sturgess and Sir Francis Albany, are a celebration of British elegance, fashion, and class. And his collaboration with another writer, Jean-Luc Fromental, has produced works like _Jamais deux sans trois_ (“Things Always Happen in Threes”), the story, inspired by the writings of F. Scott Fitzgerald, of a love triangle affecting three chic protagonists.
Floc’h’s “past covers for _The New Yorker_”:http://www.cartoonbank.com/search_results.asp?mscssid=N75BLQT1QCKS9NR183NUWJWU397MBJ28&sitetype=1&advanced=1&section=all&artist=Jean+Claude+Floc%27h always had a timeless sense of class about them, with their depictions of ski-wear, evening gowns, and well-tailored indoor wear. Floc’h loves to draw clothes, and he draws them precisely.
Floc’h’s “Michelle O” is less a caricature or portrait of Michelle Obama than a portrait of the Michelle Obama Collection, of the fashions inspired by a woman who is of course more than just a manikin. A “recent article in _The Economist_”:http://www.economist.com/world/unitedstates/displaystory.cfm?story_id=13326771 warns of the “Oprah-isation” and “Jackiefication” of a First Lady who is more than a “celebrity mother-cum-clothes-horse” and condemns the media’s obsession with Michelle’s decision, for example, to go bare-armed in public. The article refers to Floc’h’s “cover of the March 16th issue [which] features the first lady strutting on the catwalk in three different outfits (none of them featuring bare arms).” I, too, feel, like the article’s author, that “it would be good to hear a bit more about what Mrs Obama thinks and a lot less about what she wears.”
But if her fashions bring a sense of hope and color (whether those colors be summer sky blue, periwinkle, or volcanic red) to a depressed nation, there is nothing unjust or iniquitous about featuring her on the cover of “The Style Issue.” She has style, and many other qualities besides. Her thoughts and speeches, no doubt, will be the subject of other drawings -not necessarily by the fashion-loving Floc’h, but by other writers and artists who will explore other sides of her character and good sense.
The goal of Floc’h’s cover is to introduce us to the clothes of a new age, and it is a role befitting a French Anglophile who has worked on both sides of the Atlantic, and who is very modern but also very consciously inspired by fashions from earlier decades, and whose output includes as much commercial work as artistic and literary.
The First Lady’s sure-footed and self-assured style of course extends beyond the realm of fashion, but the focus here is on the excitement inspired by her goal to sweep away the dowdiness of the past four decades. Floc’h’s Michelle represents the promise and bright colors of a new era.

What’s in This Week’s New Yorker: 03.30.09

Martin Schneider writes:
A new issue of The New Yorker comes out tomorrow. Here is a description of its contents.
Atul Gawande examines the use of prolonged solitary confinement in our nation’s prisons, and concludes that whether one is serving time at a supermax prison or being held in a cell in Beirut, Hanoi, or Guantánamo Bay, “all human beings experience isolation as torture.”
Evan Osnos profiles Cheung Yan, the head of Nine Dragons Paper, China’s largest paper manufacturer, and explores how the fortunes of the company that was once the largest exporter, by volume, of freight from the United States fell to the point “that the company’s market value was less than half the value of its own phalanx of paper machines.”
David Owen writes about how bad economic times can be good for the environment.
James Surowiecki responds to Europe’s conservative reaction to the economic crisis.
David Sedaris recounts stories from his latest book tour.
Woody Allen envisions revenge on Bernie Madoff.
Alec Wilkinson profiles Chris Ferguson, one of the most successful and strategic poker pros.
John Lahr reviews West Side Story and God of Carnage.
Hilton Als explores depictions of race and prejudice in Tracey Scott Wilson’s The Good Negro.
Anthony Lane examines the life and letters of Samuel Beckett.
James Wood considers paranoid schizophrenia in John Wray’s new novel Lowboy.
Alex Ross attends Il Trovatore and La Sonnambula at the Metropolitan Opera.
Paul Goldberger revisits the work of the architect Andrea Palladio.
Nancy Franklin reviews the new television drama Kings.
David Denby reviews Duplicity and Hunger.
There is a short story by Craig Raine.

New Yorker Blog Roundup: 03.21.09

Martin Schneider writes:
Last week, a reader named Sandra wrote in to praise Ben Greenman’s flight of fancy: “This fake American Idol roundup is one of the best things I have ever read. Stunning.” Thanks for the alert, Sandra—we can always use them!
(This content is taken directly from the left nav bar on the magazine’s website.)
Steve Coll feels bureaucracy nostalgia.
James Surowiecki watches a Domino’s commercial, quotes Lenin.
George Packer looks at the Florida real estate crash…of 1929.
The Front Row: Richard Brody explains why A. O. Scott is wrong about neo-neorealism.
Elizabeth Kolbert on who’s donating to climate-change deniers.
Evan Osnos on Ralph Macchio and the Beijing dance-fight scene.
News Desk: The White House kitchen garden.
Hendrik Hertzberg on why Paul Krugman is right about Europe’s economy.
Sasha Frere-Jones recommends turning back to bass this weekend.
The Book Bench: Ann Goldstein remembers John Updike, a Scottish Armada.
The Cartoon Lounge: Dispatches from SXSW.
Goings On: American Idol does Hair, a quarter-century of Atomic Records.
Ask the Author: Submit a question to Keith Gessen about the Politkovskaya murder trial.

The Economist Presents “View of the World from … Chang’an Street”?

Martin Schneider writes:
Twitter user Michael Aphibal (michaelaphibal) makes an astute point about this week’s cover of The Economist:

Look at the cover of #TheEconomist (3/21-27/2009) The New Yorker sued Columbia Pic for imitating something similar http://tinyurl.com/2q2ybk

Good point, Michael! I’d forgotten all about Steinberg v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. (Steinberg won the case.)
So many questions! Does a news organization have more latitude on copyright infringement than a movie studio? (I’d wager yes.) Does it matter that The Economist operates out of Great Britain? Can the Saul Steinberg estate sue a British entity? (Is it inclined to?) Anyone who has seen the issue, do they credit Steinberg anywhere?
And finally, what do you think of the cover? Do you think it’s clever?
Update: Strange Maps supplies a larger view, in which one can see (as the post points out) that the image contains a billboard on the Imperial Palace with the following text: “With Apologies to Steinberg and The New Yorker.” So Steinberg is credited. Thanks to Strange Maps for the informative post.
EconomistCover.jpg

Your Guide to the New Yorker’s AMSE Nominees

Martin Schneider writes:
Today we present the New Yorker nominees for the National Magazine Awards in a way that is easier to peruse, followed by some comments about the picks.
GENERAL EXCELLENCE, Circulation 1,000,000 – 2,000,000
The New Yorker was nominated for the issues of February 11 & 18, 2008; May 26, 2008; and November 17, 2008.
REPORTING: Ryan Lizza on how Chicago shaped Barack Obama: “Making It,” July 21, 2008.
FEATURE WRITING: Nick Paumgarten on the lives of elevators: “Up and Then Down,” April 21, 2008
ESSAYS: Roger Rosenblatt on death and family: “Making Toast,” December 15, 2008
COLUMNS and COMMENTARY: Hendrik Hertzberg, Comments on Barack Obama’s visit abroad (“Foreigners,” August 4, 2008), on McCain supporters calling Obama a socialist (“Like, Socialism,” November 3, 2008), and on the passing of Proposition 8 in California (“Eight is Enough,” December 1, 2008)
REVIEWS and CRITICISM: James Wood, Books, on Richard Price and the art of dialogue (“Say What?,” April 7, 2008), on Marilynne Robinson and religion (“The Homecoming,” September 8, 2008), and on the life of V.S. Naipaul (“Wounder and Wounded,” December 1, 2008)
FICTION: Annie Proulx, “Them Old Cowboy Songs,” May 5, 2008; Aleksandar Hemon, “The Noble Truths of Suffering,” September 22, 2008; Roberto Bolaño, “Clara,” August 4, 2008; Joshua Ferris, “The Dinner Party,” August 11, 2008
LEISURE INTERESTS: Patricia Marx, On and Off the Avenue, on shopping in China (“Buy Shanghai!” July 21, 2008), on buying shoes in New York (“Sole Sisters,” September 1, 2008), and on going discount (“The Price is Right,” December 8, 2008)
PHOTO PORTFOLIO: Platon, photographs of the men and women who volunteered to serve in Iraq and Afghanistan, and their families: “Service,” September 29, 2008
It’s a resonant bunch of nominees, ones that found their way into our posts a few times, not to mention our lives. We mentioned Ryan Lizza’s article on Obama’s Chicago years here. I didn’t write about it, but at the New Yorker Festival in 2008, ASME nominee James Wood spoke at length about the nuances of ASME nominee Hendrik Hertzberg’s August 4, 2008, column about Obama’s trip abroad. We discussed Roger Rosenblatt’s essay here (Jonathan and I loved it; Benjamin didn’t); The Platon portfolio made news when Gen. Colin Powell referenced it (without naming the photographer or the magazine) during his Meet the Press endorsement of Barack Obama; we discussed the event here.

2008 Anthology of Wavy Rule Cartoons Now For Sale–Cheap!

WR-TITLE-PAGE-2008-8.PNG
_Emily Gordon writes_:
It is with great pleasure that we announce the release of _The Wavy Rule Annual: 2008_, the entire 2008 collection of cartoons by “Pollux”:http://www.flickr.com/photos/polylerus/ in one convenient paperback! As you know, “The Wavy Rule” runs every weekday on Emdashes, touching upon all things New Yorker-y, all things wavy, and all things ruley.
We are pleased to offer you the opportunity to get your own copy signed and illustrated by Pollux and shipped right to your door, gate, postern, hatchway, or portal. The anthology includes all the cartoons that ran from June 26, 2008 to December 31, 2008, and includes a foreword by yours truly.
All you have to do is send $5.00 by cash, check, or money order payable to:
Emily Gordon
Print magazine
38 E. 29th St., 3rd Floor
New York, NY 10016
Please include your name and return address.
Don’t like snail mail? Don’t trust the post office? You can also order online through “PayPal”:http://www.paypal.com. You may make a payment there to emdashes [at] gmail [dot] com.